Dan Burgess (David A.R. White) is a Christian and a senior in high school. He questions whether his commitment to Jesus is worth it or not. The guys continually make fun of his faith. He feels as if he is missing out on all the "fun". One night, he wishes he had never become a Christian. Then he finds himself taking a Second Glance and experiencing what life, his and others, would've been like if he had never accepted Christ! It's a wish he learns he should've never made."